In July 2016, Margaret Willhoite was injured in a motor vehicle accident. She sought treatment at Genesis Medical
Center. She received an X-ray to determine whether there were any broken ribs. Although the X-ray was negative for fractures, it indicated a nodule in her left lung. And her medical records noted that she should receive a computerized
tomography (CT) scan of her chest to investigate the nodule. But no CT scan was ordered or conducted. Margaret was released.
In March 2018, Margaret suffered a fracture to her left femur. She received care at a different hospital. This time, a CT scan was performed. The scan revealed tumors in her left lung, left femur, left adrenal gland, and right scapula. She was diagnosed with cancer. In May, she passed away as a result of the cancer.
In January 2020, a team of lawyers filed an Iowa wrongful-death medical malpractice suit against Genesis Medical Center and several providers who cared for Margaret following her July 2016 accident. The defendants answered in February and March, which started sixty-day clocks for the plaintiffs to serve certificate of merit affidavits under Iowa Code section 147.140 (2020). The plaintiffs timely served certificates in March, April, and May.
Each certificate was entitled, “Certificate of Merit Affidavit of [a particular expert].” Each certificate opened by stating, “In compliance with Iowa Code § 147.140, [the expert], does hereby affirm and state as follows: . . . .” Each certificate was dated and signed by a certifying expert. But none of the certificates included a notary stamp or jurat. And none of the certificates included a statement that it was signed under penalty of perjury.
Genesis filed a motion to dismiss in June. Genesis noted that the plaintiffs’ 2020 certificates did not “contain a jurat demonstrating that an oath or affirmation was properly conducted on each of the expert witnesses.” “Nor [were the] certificates of merit signed under penalty of perjury pursuant to Iowa Code section 622.1.” Therefore, Genesis argued, the plaintiffs’ certificates did not comply with section 147.140’s “affidavit” requirement.
On July 30, the district court granted Genesis’s motion to dismiss with prejudice. On August 28, Patrick Willhoite, the executor of the two plaintiffs-estates, filed a document entitled “Pro Se Appearance” that was purportedly made “for and on behalf of the Plaintiffs.” The same day, Patrick filed a notice of appeal on behalf of the plaintiffs, each of whom was identified as an appealing party. On August 29, an amended notice of appeal was filed on behalf of the plaintiffs. The amended notice was filed through an efiling account assigned to an Iowa attorney.
On October 2, Genesis moved to dismiss the appeal by Margaret’s estate and Michael’s estate. Genesis argued that Patrick had engaged in the unauthorized practice of law by filing notices of appeal on behalf of the estates. And the remedy for this unauthorized practice, Genesis argued, was to treat the estates’ notices as nullities.
The Iowa Supreme Court held in its May 22, 2026 decision: “Patrick’s filing of notices of appeal for his parents’ estates was also unauthorized practice … [however] the administrator’s unauthorized filings did not have to be treated as nullities, Patrick’s unauthorized notices of appeal do not have to be treated as nullities. See Tornell, 31 N.W.3d at 170. Therefore, dismissal is not necessarily required. Id. Instead, as in Tornell, what is important is that Patrick’s unauthorized practice must end, and all future filings must be made by licensed attorneys. Id. Thus, Tornell suggests we should give the estates a reasonable amount of time to obtain counsel … But that problem has already been solved. Indeed, it appears that the estates have always been represented by counsel at all stages of this case. As explained, lawyers from two law firms appeared on behalf of the estates throughout the district court proceedings. And at least some of those lawyers never sought or received leave to withdraw either in the district court or in our court … At least one of those lawyers (Duchesneau) assisted Patrick in filing the amended notice of appeal. That aside, a new lawyer, Matthew Sease, has now appeared in this appellate case on behalf of all plaintiffs. His appearance was filed less than a month after the appeal was filed. And Sease has handled all of the briefing and motion practice in this court. Since his appearance, there have been no additional unauthorized filings by Patrick. Thus, the twin goals identified in Tornell—“halt[ing] the unauthorized practice of law by nonlawyers attempting to represent others while also permitting resolution of the dispute on the merits (assuming counsel timely appears in the case)”—have been fulfilled. 31 N.W.3d at 170. So we decline to dismiss the estates’ appeal.”
“We turn now to the substantive issue: should we reverse the district court’s decision to dismiss the plaintiffs’ suit because of their failure to comply with Iowa Code section 147.140, our certificate of merit affidavit statute? As to this question, we are evenly divided … Because we are evenly divided, the district court is affirmed by operation of law. Iowa Code § 602.4107 (2026) … The motion to dismiss this appeal is denied. As to the merits issue of whether the district court erred by dismissing the plaintiffs’ lawsuit: because the court is evenly divided, the dismissal is affirmed by operation of law,”
Source Willhoite v. Genesis Health System, No. 24–1380.
If you or a loved one suffered a serious injury (or worse) as a result of medical negligence in Iowa or in another U.S. state, you should promptly find an Iowa medical malpractice lawyer, or a medical malpractice in your state, who may investigate your medical malpractice claim for you and represent you or your loved one in a medical malpractice case, if appropriate.
Click on the “Contact Us Now” tab to the right, visit our website, or call us toll-free in the United States at 800-295-3959 to find medical malpractice attorneys in your state who may assist you.
Turn to us when you don’t know where to turn.

