Lucia Urizar-Mota (“Urizar-Mota”), a homemaker and mother of four, filed a medical negligence claim pursuant to the Federal Tort Claims Act (“FTCA”), 28 U.S.C. §§ 1346(b), 2671–80, alleging that her doctors and nurse practitioner at
Providence Community Health Center (“PCHC”), a federally funded health center, breached their duty of care by failing to refer her to a neurologist or for neuroimaging that could have detected a slow-growing tumor in the fourth ventricle of her brain. Instead, the tumor — left undetected — grew and caused an abnormal buildup of cerebral fluid. During the eventual surgery to resect the tumor, Urizar-Mota suffered cerebellar strokes, resulting in permanent neurological damage that continues to impact her mobility and daily life functions — including her provision of homemaker services to her husband and children.

After motions practice and then a bench trial, the district court awarded Urizar-Mota damages for post-diagnosis medical expenses; pre- and post-diagnosis pain and suffering; and homemaker loss. Further, the district court awarded Urizar-Mota’s children damages for loss of consortium.

The United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit stated in its March 27, 2026 Opinion: “Urizar-Mota’s “individual administrative claim is not sufficient under the FTCA to serve as notice to the government of potential loss-of-consortium claims by other family members that could be derived from [her] claim” … The “derivative nature” of the Reyes Plaintiffs’ claims “does not excuse [their] failure to comply with the FTCA exhaustion requirements.””

Loss Of Homemaker Services Award

“[T]he district court awarded her $2.92 million in damages to make up for the “economic loss to her” due to her
inability to perform homemaking duties … We conclude that the district court’s award of homemaker damages was premised on a meaningful error … The plain language of Section 9-1-47 requires us to vacate the district court’s homemaker damages award as both unsupported by the evidence and grossly excessive. As set forth in the statute, a person may only “recover the fair value of homemaker services provided to the home and those living therein.” R.I. Gen. Laws § 9-1-47 (emphasis added). Thus, any award under the statute must reflect a reasonable estimate of the services that would have been provided by the homemaker over time, absent personal injury … The district court ignored the plain meaning of the statute when it awarded damages based on an assumption, unsupported by evidence, that — absent her permanent injuries — Urizar-Mota would have continued to provide “homemaker services” under the statute for the entirety of her remaining fifty-year life expectancy at a consistent number of hours each day … by failing to consider that her hours spent caring for her family would have decreased when her children moved out of her home — likely long before the end of Urizar-Mota’s life — and that she might then have lacked primary responsibility for the care of a family and home depending on the division of responsibilities (if any) with her spouse and/or her age and health, the district court produced a grossly excessive damages award, unsupported by the limited evidence Urizar-Mota provided. Accordingly, we vacate the homeowner damages award” … We accordingly remand to the district court with instructions to first determine whether, as the government argues, Urizar-Mota waived the right to recover homemaker damages and, if not, to recalculate those damages consistent with this opinion.”

The federal appellate court held: “We hold that the district court lacked jurisdiction over the Reyes Plaintiffs’
loss-of-consortium claims and reverse the awards of loss-of-consortium damages. We hold that the district court’s
per-diem calculation of homemaker damages was unsupported by the evidence and grossly excessive in light of the plain meaning of R.I. Gen. Laws § 9-1-47 and therefore vacate the homemaker damages award and remand with instructions to the district court for further proceedings regarding homemaker damages. We further hold that the district court did not err, or committed only harmless error, as to the breach and causation determinations and
accordingly affirm the pre- and post-diagnosis pain and suffering damages awards. Finally, we modify the district court’s award of medical expenses, reducing that award by the cost of Urizar-Mota’s spinal MRI ($3,600).”

Source Urizar-Mota v. United States, No. 25-1131.

If you or a loved one suffered harm as a result of medical malpractice involving a federal medical facility or involving a federal employee, you should promptly find a federal medical malpractice lawyer (Federal Tort Claims Act lawyer) who may investigate your federal medical malpractice claim for you and represent you or your loved one in a Federal Tort Claims Act medical malpractice case, if appropriate.

Click here to visit our website or call us toll-free in the United States at 800-295-3959 to find FTCA medical malpractice attorneys in your U.S. state who may assist you. 

Turn to us when you don’t know where to turn.

Summary
Federal Appellate Court Vacates Loss Of Homemaker Services Award In FTCA Medical Malpractice Case
Article Name
Federal Appellate Court Vacates Loss Of Homemaker Services Award In FTCA Medical Malpractice Case
Description
Lucia Urizar-Mota ("Urizar-Mota"), a homemaker and mother of four, filed a medical negligence claim pursuant to the Federal Tort Claims...
Author
Publisher Name
Medical Malpractice Lawyers
Publisher Logo