On June 30, 2021, Renee Jauregui (“Jauregui”) filed a complaint asserting a medical malpractice claim against Dr. Cothran. In her complaint, Jauregui claimed that she had seen Dr. Cothran, an OB/GYN, for several pregnancy related visits between May and October 2018. Jauregui alleged that, during at least four of the appointments, she informed Dr. Cothran of a lump she had discovered in her breast. According to Jauregui, Dr. Cothran told her that there was no reason for concern, the lump was a normal part of pregnancy, and diagnostic testing would not display useful information. In August 2019, Jauregui returned to Dr. Cothran for a follow up on the breast lump and subsequent testing revealed that the lump was breast cancer.
Dr. Cothran filed a plea in bar asserting that the statute of limitations barred Jauregui’s claim. The parties agreed that the statute of limitations would bar any claims related to any appointments prior to the August 2019 appointment. As a result, the dispositive legal issue became whether the continuing treatment rule applied to extend the statute of limitations to include Jauregui’s previous appointments with Dr. Cothran.
The Virginia Supreme Court stated in its December 30, 2025 Opinion: “The continuing treatment rule operates as an exception to the two-year statute of limitations for medical malpractice actions. Under the continuing treatment rule,
when malpractice is claimed to have occurred during a continuous and substantially uninterrupted course of examination and treatment in which a particular illness or condition should have been diagnosed in the exercise of reasonable care, the date of injury occurs, the cause of action for that malpractice accrues, and the statute of limitations commences to run when the improper course of examination, and treatment if any, for the particular malady terminates … it is not actually a rule, it is an exception to the statute of limitations.”
“Taken as a whole, the proper application of the continuing treatment rule focuses on the existence of a continuous and uninterrupted relationship between a physician and a patient with regard to a specific injury, condition, or malady. Once such a relationship is established, the rule delays the accrual of a malpractice action related to the examination and treatment of that specific injury, condition, or malady until the relationship ceases … the “examination” aspect of the rule necessarily includes a mistaken diagnosis or a failure to diagnose, just as the “treatment” aspect necessarily includes improper treatment or a failure to treat.”
“In the present case, the trial court clearly based part of its decision to grant the plea in bar on its determination that “there was certainly not a continuous and substantially uninterrupted course of treatment because there was no treatment at all that was being administered by a doctor in this case.” The absence of treatment, while certainly a factor to consider, is not, in and of itself, dispositive of the application of the continuing treatment rule. Therefore, if the absence of treatment were the sole basis for the trial court’s decision, it would certainly be error. The trial court, however, did not limit its ruling to just the lack of treatment. It also concluded that “there was also no continuous and substantially uninterrupted course of examination … Proper application of the continuing treatment rule “presupposes” the existence of “a continuous course of improper examination or treatment which is substantially uninterrupted;” it does not apply to a singular or isolated act of malpractice.”
“Given that “continuous treatment” refers to the physician/patient relationship with regard to the “same or related illnesses or injuries,” id. at 979, the phrase “substantially uninterrupted” must mean something different to avoid redundancy. Accordingly, we hold that the Court of Appeals erred when it used the definition “continuous treatment” interchangeably with “substantially uninterrupted” … the phrase refers to a physician/patient relationship that is mostly, but not necessarily entirely, continuous. Stated another way, the phrase “substantially uninterrupted” simply adds a layer of reasonableness into the continuity requirement.”
The Virginia Supreme Court concluded in the case it was deciding: “Viewed in this context, we are persuaded by the trial court’s rationale that a substantial interruption occurred. As the trial court explained, at least one of the parties had reasonably concluded that the course of examination or treatment had reached its logical conclusion and “nobody was forecasting that at that point that there was going to be any need for any treatment or any examination.” It is undisputed that, after the October 2018 appointment, there was an interruption in the course of examination and treatment. During that time, both parties proceeded as though the physician/patient relationship had ended. Although there was a possibility that Jauregui might return to see Dr. Cothran about the lump in her breast at some unknown point in the future, the fact remains that the physician/patient relationship was interrupted, and the longer that interruption continued, the more substantial it became. Approximately ten months later, in August 2019, Jauregui returned. Under these circumstances, we cannot say that the trial court’s finding that this amounted to a substantial interruption in the course of examination was plainly wrong or without evidence to support it. Thus, the trial court did not err in sustaining the plea in bar. For the foregoing reasons, we will reverse the decision of the Court of Appeals and
reinstate the trial court’s decision sustaining Dr. Cothran’s plea in bar.”
Source Cothran, M.D. v. Jauregui, Record No. 250019.
If you or a loved one were injured as a result of the misdiagnosis of cancer in Virginia or in another U.S. state, you should promptly consult with a Virginia medical malpractice attorney, or a medical malpractice attorney in your state, who may investigate your cancer misdiagnosis claim for you and represent you or your loved one in a cancer medical malpractice case, if appropriate.
Visit our website or call us toll-free in the United States at 800-295-3959 to be connected with medical malpractice lawyers in Virginia or in your U.S. state who may assist you.
Turn to us when you don’t know where to turn.

