Renee Jauregui filed a complaint in Fairfax County Circuit Court on June 30, 2021, asserting a medical malpractice claim against Dr. Shannon J. Cothran and Capital Women’s Care, LLC. Jauregui alleged that she informed Dr. Cothran of a lump in her breast during four pregnancy-related visits with Dr. Cothran between May and October 2018. The complaint stated that Dr. Cothran told Jauregui there was no reason for concern, that the lump was a normal response to pregnancy, and that diagnostic testing would not display any useful information. The complaint claimed that Jauregui “did not seek a mammogram or ultrasound” due to this advice, but returned to Dr. Cothran in August 2019 to follow-up on the lump. Subsequent diagnostic testing revealed the lump was breast cancer. The complaint asserted that Dr. Cothran’s negligence in failing to properly diagnose or treat Jauregui for her symptoms resulted in a metastasized cancer significantly more difficult to treat. Jauregui argued that she was entitled to compensation for medical malpractice.

Dr. Cothran filed a plea in bar asserting that the two-year statute of limitations under Code § 8.01-243(A) precluded Jauregui’s claim. The controlling legal issue rested on whether Virginia’s “continuing treatment rule,” which tolls the statute of limitations for medical malpractice until the course of improper examination and treatment ends, served to extend the statute of limitations beyond the date of the October 2018 visit, the last date that Dr. Cothran provided any alleged improper treatment for the negligently diagnosed condition.

Dr. Cothran argued by motion that she provided no examination or treatment for Jauregui’s symptoms until the August 2019 visit; thus, there was no “continuous and substantially uninterrupted” treatment during that period. Jauregui argued by brief that the facts set forth in the complaint fell within the continuing treatment rule.

Continuing Treatment Rule

The continuing treatment rule provides that when medical malpractice is claimed to have occurred during a continuous and substantially uninterrupted course of examination and treatment in which a particular illness or condition should have been diagnosed in the exercise of reasonable care, the date of injury occurs, the cause of action for that malpractice accrues, and the statute of limitations commences to run when the improper course of examination, and treatment if any, for the particular malady terminates.

The Court of Appeals of Virginia stated in its unpublished Memorandum Opinion dated on November 12, 2024: “Dr. Cothran examined Jauregui based on specific, on-going complaints. That examination led to an incorrect diagnosis which delayed the necessary treatment. This entire process constitutes “examination and treatment” … the relevant question in determining whether the course of examination was “substantially uninterrupted” is not merely whether there was an ongoing physician-patient relationship, but whether that relationship concerns the “same or related illnesses or injuries” … So, in this case, Dr. Cothran’s expectations about whether Jauregui would return are not dispositive; rather, what matters is that Jauregui later did return, pursuant to Dr. Cothran’s instructions, for further examination of the same condition. When Jauregui raised her concerns in the October 2018 visit, Dr. Cothran provided a diagnosis of a clogged milk duct. Dr. Cothran examined the lump and, as the circuit court recognized, instructed Jauregui that if she noticed any changes, she should call the office and set up another appointment. Trusting that advice, Jauregui monitored her lump and scheduled a follow-up appointment, when necessary, pursuant to Dr. Cothran’s instructions. Jauregui’s behavior between October 2018 and August 2019 can be directly attributed to Dr. Cothran’s instructions. When Jauregui then returned in August 2019 after following that plan, the diagnostic testing and discovery of cancer was part of a “continuous and substantially uninterrupted course of examination” of Jauregui’s breast lump, because the October 2018 and August 2019 visits centered on “the same or [a] related illness or injur[y].””

The Virginia appellate court held that the circuit court erred in failing to apply the continuing treatment rule to Jauregui’s statute of limitations.

Source Jauregui v. Cothran, M.D., Record No. 1133-23-4.

***OVERTURNED BY THE VIRGINIA SUPREME COURT IN ITS OPINION DATED DECEMBER 30, 2025***

If you or a loved one were injured as a result of the misdiagnosis of cancer in Virginia or in another U.S. state, you should promptly consult with a Virginia medical malpractice attorney, or a medical malpractice attorney in your state, who may investigate your cancer misdiagnosis claim for you and represent you or your loved one in a cancer medical malpractice case, if appropriate.

Visit our website or call us toll-free in the United States at 800-295-3959 to be connected with medical malpractice lawyers in Virginia or in your U.S. state who may assist you.

Turn to us when you don’t know where to turn.

Summary
Virginia Appellate Court Applies Continuing Treatment Rule In Reinstating Medical Malpractice Case
Article Name
Virginia Appellate Court Applies Continuing Treatment Rule In Reinstating Medical Malpractice Case
Description
Renee Jauregui filed a complaint in Fairfax County Circuit Court on June 30, 2021, asserting a medical malpractice claim against Dr...
Author
Publisher Name
Medical Malpractice Lawyers
Publisher Logo