The plaintiff, John Armour, individually and as personal representative of the Estate of Judith Armour, appealed from the denial of his motion for a new trial following a verdict for the defendants David Bader, M.D., Neil Brandon, M.D., and South County Hospital Healthcare System d.b.a. South County Cardiology in a medical negligence case. The plaintiff challenged the trial justice’s refusal to give a jury instruction pursuant to the instruction affirmed by the Rhode Island Supreme Court in Oliveira v. Jacobson, 846 A.2d 822 (R.I. 2004). The plaintiff also claimed that the trial justice erred in permitting the defendants’ standard-of-care expert to utilize a referring doctor’s records as a basis for his opinions and in limiting cross-examination of that expert regarding a particular study.
Oliveira v. Jacobson
The Rhode Island Supreme Court held in Oliveira that the trial justice properly narrowed the jury’s focus to the issue of the defendant-doctors’ negligence. The plaintiffs’ claims in Oliveira concerned the defendant-doctors’ failure to timely
perform a cesarean section. The plaintiffs argued that the standard of care required defendants to deliver the infant by cesarean section, and the additional delay caused by the defendant-doctors’ attempts to deliver the infant vaginally was the proximate cause of the infant’s death by asphyxiation. After several unsuccessful attempts, the defendant-doctors sought the assistance of another attending physician at the hospital. The Oliveira defendants sought to use the nonparty doctor’s conduct to argue that they did not act negligently in providing the same treatment. The Rhode Island Supreme Court rejected that argument and found defendants’ reasoning “untenable.” While physicians are held to the duty of care expected of a reasonably competent practitioner acting under similar circumstances, the defendant-doctors in Oliveira were not operating under similar circumstances as the nonparty doctor, who provided emergency care after the alleged negligence had already occurred. The difference in time, place and skill level distinguish the level of care provided by the defendants and the nonparty doctor so that the trial justice’s instruction to the jury was correct and warranted.
The Rhode Island Supreme Court held in its June 28, 2024 Opinion in the present case that the trial justice erred in denying the plaintiff’s motion for a new trial because (1) the jury should have been instructed that it would be improper to consider the nonparty referring physician’s conduct in assessing the defendants’ negligence in this case (“It is well settled that “we hold physicians to a duty of care that is expected of a reasonably competent practitioner acting under similar circumstances“); (2) allowing the defendants’ standard-of-care expert to rely on the specific content of the referring physician’s records, a primary-care provider, to support the defendant-cardiologists’ actions on the date of the decedent’s stress test, when they were admittedly not available to the defendants, was an abuse of discretion (“Although admitted into evidence as a full exhibit, the records were relevant for purposes of causation. The defendants’ attempt to utilize these records to support their standard-of-care defense was misplaced. We have held that an expert witness must base their opinion “upon facts legally sufficient to form a basis for his conclusion” … We conclude that it was an error to allow the expert to use the decedent’s primary-care provider’s records to support his opinions as defendants did not have access to this information when determining if she was stable … Here, to allow the expert cardiologist’s testimony utilizing the specific content of the referring physician’s records, a primary-care provider, to support the defendant-cardiologists’ actions on the date of her stress test, when they were admittedly not available to defendants, was an abuse of discretion”); and (3) it was an error to preclude the plaintiff’s attorney from referencing a particular study by name on cross-examination of the defendants’ expert because, although outside the scope of direct examination, it would have tended to contradict the expert’s testimony that the decedent was stable on the date of her stress echocardiogram. Accordingly, the Rhode Island Supreme Court vacated the judgment of the Superior Court and remanded the case for a new trial.
Source Armour v. Bader, M.D., No. 2023-5-Appeal.
If you or your loved one may have been injured as a result of medical malpractice in Rhode Island or in another U.S. state, you should promptly find a Rhode Island medical malpractice lawyer, or a medical malpractice lawyer in your state, who may investigate your medical malpractice claim for you and represent you or your loved one in a medical malpractice case, if appropriate.
Click here to visit our website or call us toll-free in the United States at 800-295-3959 to find medical malpractice attorneys in your state who may assist you.
Turn to us when you don’t know where to turn.

