Plaintiff Ronald Madison first presented to defendant Michael P. Bradley, M.D. at South County Ortho on September 9, 2013, with complaints of right hip pain and swelling. At that appointment, it was determined that Mr. Madison needed a right total hip arthroplasty because conservative therapy had given him no relief. Dr. Bradley operated on Mr. Madison at South County Hospital. When Mr. Madison awoke from the surgery, he noticed that his right foot was pronating to the right.

On July 12, 2018, nearly five years after the September 2013 surgery, Mr. Madison filed his Rhode Island medical malpractice complaint against the defendants. The Complaint contains various causes of action including a count of medical malpractice, a count of vicarious liability, and a count of negligent credentialing, among others.

In answering interrogatory number 24, Mr. Madison stated that he first suspected Dr. Bradley’s negligence after an August 26, 2015 corrective surgery, after Dr. Bradley recommended that Mr. Madison get a second opinion. During his deposition, Mr. Madison also testified that in his mind he believed that Dr. Bradley had done something wrong after the September 2013 Surgery. In his affidavit, Plaintiff also attested that his current memory and memory at the time of the deposition was not anywhere as fresh as it was when he answered his interrogatories. Plaintiff’s expert, Dr. Cornell, attested that “there was not any possible way that Mr. Madison or any reasonable patient could have known or suspected that an undersized stem was used absent the findings of the July 16, 2015 bone scan and the surgeon informing the patient of suspicion that the stem was undersized, which, according to the evidence in this case, did not
occur until July 27, 2015.”

Under Rhode Island law:

“Notwithstanding the provisions of §§ 9-1-13 and 9-1-14, an action for medical . . . malpractice shall be commenced within three (3) years from the time of the occurrence of the incident that gave rise to the action; provided, however, that:

“. . .

“(3) In respect to those injuries or damages due to acts of medical . . . malpractice that could not in the exercise of reasonable diligence be discoverable at the time of the occurrence of the incident that gave rise to the action, suit shall be commenced within three (3) years of the time that the act or acts of the malpractice should, in the exercise of reasonable diligence, have been discovered.”

G.L. 1956 § 9-1-14.1(3).

Under Rhode Island Law, the discovery date is the date that the plaintiff knew or should have known of the wrongful act that is the basis of their lawsuit. An injury is latent and potentially undiscoverable when, exercising reasonable diligence at the time of the injury, a plaintiff is unable to discover the wrongful act, neglect or default.

The Rhode Island Superior Court stated in its Decision filed on Sepetmebr 20, 2024, “the Court is hard-pressed to believe that Mr. Madison personally knew of any wrongful conduct from the September 2013 Surgery prior to his suspicion being raised by ordering the bone scan on July 13, 2015 because he routinely met with Dr. Bradley even after the allegedly negligent surgery. At all those postoperative meetings, Dr. Bradley noted that Mr. Madison was progressing well. See Evidentiary Hr’g Exs. 2-5. Regarding the pain he had, Mr. Madison stated that it was no worse than the pain he had prior to the September 2013 Surgery. (June 27, 2024 Evidentiary Hr’g Tr. at 21:14-17.) The postoperative notes also demonstrate that Dr. Bradley continued to treat Mr. Madison for pain without sufficient explanation as to why the pain persisted even after the surgery … Neither the pronation of his right foot nor the resulting pain is the “wrongful conduct” alleged in Mr. Madison’s Complaint … viewing all the evidence, this Court finds that Defendants have not met their burden showing that Mr. Madison knew of the allegedly wrongful conduct from the September 2013 Surgery until some point after the July 16, 2015 bone scan, which falls within the statute of limitations … the Court cannot say that a reasonable person exercising reasonable diligence would be put on notice of a potential claim from the September 2013 Surgery. It is wholly reasonable to rely on one’s own doctor who has continued to provide explanations as to why pain continues post-surgery … No reasonable diligence could be had if a doctor keeps saying that another issue not related to the surgery is causing the pain. Postoperative notes show that Dr. Bradley told Mr. Madison that his issues with pain could have been stemming from problems not related to the September 2013 Surgery.”

THe Rhode Island Superior Court held: “For all the reasons above, Mr. Madison did not know malpractice had occurred and it was not reasonable that he should have known that malpractice occurred on the day of or near the September 2013 Surgery. The statute of limitations on the alleged medical malpractice stemming from the September 2013 Surgery began to run after the July 16, 2015 bone scan indicating that there was loosening of the femoral stem. Plaintiff filed his Complaint on July 12, 2018, within the three-year statute of limitations as provided under Rhode Island law. Therefore, this Court DENIES Defendants’ Partial Motion for Summary Judgment.”

Source Madison v. Bradley, M.D., C.A. No. KC-2018-0774.

If you or your loved one may have been injured as a result of medical malpractice in Rhode Island or in another U.S. state, you should promptly find a Rhode Island medical malpractice lawyer, or a medical malpractice lawyer in your state, who may investigate your medical malpractice claim for you and represent you or your loved one in a medical malpractice case, if appropriate.

Click here to visit our website or call us toll-free in the United States at 800-295-3959 to find medical malpractice attorneys in your state who may assist you.

Turn to us when you don’t know where to turn.

Summary
Rhode Island Superior Court Finds Surgical  Medical Malpractice Case Not Filed Too Late
Article Name
Rhode Island Superior Court Finds Surgical Medical Malpractice Case Not Filed Too Late
Description
Plaintiff Ronald Madison first presented to defendant Michael P. Bradley, M.D. at South County Ortho on September 9, 2013, with complaints...
Author
Publisher Name
Medical Malpractice Lawyers
Publisher Logo