On October 11, 2018, Dr. Tamica White performed a surgery at WellStar Hospital to remove Amy McGouirk’s gallbladder. During the surgery, Dr. White transected or cut Amy’s common bile duct. Following the transection, Amy was transferred to Emory University Hospital where she remained for five days. A different surgeon, Dr. Sarmiento, advised against an immediate repair of the bile duct injury.
On December 6, 2018, Dr. Sarmiento attempted to repair the bile duct, but could not complete the repair because
Amy’s liver was “extremely fatty, really friable, [and] in a tremendously difficult condition.” Dr. Sarmiento advised Amy to wait six months or a year before attempting the repair again because any surgery would have caused her liver to disintegrate and fall apart. The wound from the attempted repair was left open so that it could heal from the inside out and when the wound dressing became saturated, Amy’s husband would have to change the packing, which he did for approximately six months.
In the meantime, in order for the bile to go back into the intestines, Dr. Sarmiento inserted a feeding tube into Amy’s stomach to“refeed [her] bile”; a biliary drain to drain bile outside of Amy’s body; and a bile bag. The bile bag collects the bile which is then manually “squirted back into the [feeding] tube” by the patient; according to Amy, she had to refeed the bile at least seven times a day. If she did not perform the procedure slow enough, it would “make [her] very nauseous [a]nd [she] would feel like [she] was throwing up.” Amy had to wear the bile bag until a repair could be completed. On several occasions, Amy was hospitalized for sepsis resulting from infection of the wound as well as feeding tube and bile tube issues. Dr. Sarmiento repaired the bile duct in early October 2019, and three weeks later, all the drains and bags were removed. In July 2020, Amy underwent surgery for four ventral incisional hernias, related to the repair.
According to Amy’s expert, the pain from incisional hernias can “be life-long” and patients who have had a bile duct injury have a decreased life expectancy. Amy is also at risk for stricture or a narrowing of the connection between the bile duct and intestine because of scarring, which can result in an infection inside the bile duct, requiring hospitalization. She also must be monitored yearly for the rest of her life for signs or symptoms of a biliary stricture or liver damage.
Amy incurred medical expenses in excess of $900,000, and lost wages of $26,000 per year. Amy and her husband sued Dr. White and WellStar Medical Group for medical malpractice and loss of consortium and sought damages for pain and suffering, all past and future medical expenses and economic damage, including lost wages and the loss of consortium claim. The jury found in favor of the McGouirks and awarded $10,000,000 in general compensatory damages to Amy and $100,000 to her husband for loss of consortium. The trial court subsequently entered judgment on the verdict after which the defendants appealed.
The Court of Appeals of Georgia Fifth Division stated in its January 11, 2024 opinion: “The defendants contend that the trial court erred in denying their motion for mistrial and amended motion for new trial because the McGouirks’ counsel repeatedly and improperly implored the jury to “send a message” with their verdict … we agree with the trial court that the word “responsibility” is not synonymous with “punitive” and do not find that the McGouirk’s statements improperly asked the jury to “send a message” or to award punitive damages … even if we were to assume that the statements made during closing argument were improper, we do not find that the improper arguments permeated the trial such that a new trial is required … In this case, one instance during opening statements and two during closing arguments do not amount to an attempt by counsel to establish improper motive throughout the trial.”
“We conclude that the McGouirks’ statements did not amount to an argument that the defendants must be punished and penalized so that the conduct will never occur again. See Carlin, 196 Ga. App. at 55 (3). Accordingly, the trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying their motion for mistrial and amended motion for new trial … In light of the evidence, we cannot say that the verdict and damages award was so flagrantly excessive as to shock the conscience.”
Source White v. McGouirk, A23A1548.
If you or a loved one may have been injured (or worse) as a result of medical malpractice in Georgia or in another U.S. state, you should promptly find a Georgia medical malpractice lawyer, or a medical malpractice lawyer in your state, who may investigate your medical malpractice claim for you and represent you or your loved one in a medical malpractice case, if appropriate.
Click here to visit our website or call us toll-free in the United States at 800-295-3959 to find medical malpractice attorneys in your state who may assist you.
Turn to us when you don’t know where to turn.
