
Communication Failures Involved In 49% Of Medical Malpractice Claims: A study published earlier this year in the Journal of Patient Safety reported: “Communication failures were identified in 49% of claims. Claims with communication failures were significantly less likely to be dropped, denied, or dismissed than claims without (54% versus 67%, P = 0.015). Fifty-three percent of claims with communication failures involved provider-patient miscommunication, and 47% involved provider-provider miscommunication. The information types most frequently miscommunicated were contingency plans, diagnosis, and illness severity. Forty percent of communication failures involved a failed handoff; the majority could potentially have been averted by using a handoff tool (77%). Mean total costs for cases involving communication failures were higher ($237,600 versus $154,100, P = 0.005).”
The authors of the study reviewed a random sample of malpractice claims from 2001 to 2011 in a national claims database to determine if a claim involved communication failure, its type, and potential preventability using a communication tool. Interrater reliability was assessed by dual review of 50 cases (81% agreement, κ = 0.62 for evidence of miscommunication). Claimant demographics, case characteristics, and financial data were analyzed.
The authors concluded: “Communication failures are a significant contributing cause of malpractice claims and impose a substantial financial burden on the healthcare system. Interventions to improve transmission of critical patient information have the potential to substantially reduce malpractice expenditures.”
A report from early 2016 found that communication problems were a contributing factor in 7,149 medical malpractice claims of 23,658 medical malpractice claims filed between 2009 and 2013, which includes 1,744 deaths and $1.7 billion in hospital costs. In addition, 37 percent of all high-severity injury cases involved communication failures.
The report noted that common breakdowns in communication include miscommunication about a patient’s condition, inadequate informed consent, poor documentation and an unsympathetic response to a patient’s complaint.
Source
One definition of a hand-off is a transfer and acceptance of patient care responsibility achieved through effective communication. It is a real-time process of passing patient-specific information from one caregiver to another or from one team of caregivers to another, to ensure the continuity and safety of the patient’s care. The Joint Commission warns: “It’s estimated that a typical teaching hospital may experience more than 4,000 hand-offs every day. However, sometimes hand-offs are conducted too casually, when they should be structured and focused to ensure continuity of care … While it sounds simple, a high-quality hand-off is complex. Failed hand-offs are a longstanding, common problem in health care.”
“Potential for patient harm – from the minor to the severe – is introduced when the receiver gets information that is inaccurate, incomplete, not timely, misinterpreted, or otherwise not what is needed. When hand-off communication fails, many factors are involved, such as health care provider training and expectations, language barriers, cultural or ethnic considerations, and inadequate, incomplete or nonexistent documentation, to name just a few.”
